I love the historian’s craft. I love doing research. And I particularly love it when I find a new source that provides information from a new angle about an event that I already know about. Recently, I was incredibly thrilled to stumble across a previously unknown painting of the Great Buffalo Roundup, by none other than famous western artist Charles M. Russell. Even better, it was depicting an anecdote that I love, about a photographer called Norman Forsyth nearly being trampled to death by bison he was trying to photograph, and it lead me to find even more images of the incident.
In 1907-1912, over 600 wild bison owned by Michel Pablo were rounded up an sold to the Canadian government, to ultimately end up at Elk Island, Banff, and Buffalo National Parks. I had known previously that artist Charles Russell was at the roundup. There were several photographers who were present, as well, including Norman Luxton from Banff and the aforementioned Forsyth. The roundup attracted a lot of media attention. One analogy I’ve used is that it was as if they were herding dinosaurs – this was within one generation of the near complete loss of bison in North America and their continued preservation was by no means certain.
A stereograph by Forsyth called “Goodbye Uncle Sam, I am a Subject of the King”. (Referring to going to the Dominion of Canada, whose head of state at the time was the king of Great Britain.) Image from the Montana Historical Society. Forsyth took stereographs, which were pairs of photographs captured by a camera with two lenses, which are the same distance apart as human eyeballs. When printed side by side like this one and then viewed through a special reader, they become 3D. They were super popular about 120 years ago.So these two photographs are actually ever so slightly different.You can tell that different photographers were working alongside each other, even taking photographs of the same scenes from the same or slightly different angles. This is almost the same photograph as the one above by Forsyth, but this one was taken by Banff-based photographer Norman Luxton. His photographs were in a very different format, with a very long and skinny ratio. His photos are reproduced without named credit in the booklet “The Last of the Buffalo”. A low resolution copy of the booklet is found here on Peel’s Prairie Provinces. For more about Luxton, bison conservation history, and bison in Banff, and to see a facsimile of this booklet with photographs of actually decent quality, check out Harvey Locke’s book on the subject, The Last of the Buffalo Return to the Wild.
Russell made a lot of sketches; he ultimately became famous for paintings and statues of a sort of romanticized past on the American western frontier. He also depicted a lot of buffalo in his paintings, and Indigenous people hunting buffalo on horseback. His depictions of bison are spot on, in terms of their looks, the way they move, and their body language. And he knew this because he observed a bunch of Blackfoot and Mexican cowboys round up hundreds of bison during the Great Buffalo Roundup. You can really see how observing the roundup influenced his art.
Last week, a colleague at Elk Island National Park, where I used to work, was reprinting a few worn out props (historical photographs printed on foam core), and needed to locate the high quality source files. Taking one look at the photos, I immediately identified them as one half of one of Forsyth’s stereographs taken at the roundup. I didn’t have a copy on hand, but I knew that the Montana Historical Society had a bunch of his stereographs in their archives, so I hopped onto their database to find him the entries so that he could order new digital copies.
Now, there are 500+ image files attributed to Forsyth in that archive, and since I wasn’t sure if all of them from the roundup had “buffalo” or “bison” in the title or tags, I decided to just scroll through all of the images attributed to him to make sure I didn’t miss one of the ones he was looking for. He has some of different American national parks, plus some taken at a Kootenai sun dance gathering, plus the photos from the series I was looking for. I reproduced several of his photographs in my book so I’m pretty familiar with his work, but as I scrolled I found a few images I didn’t recognize.
Now, one of my favourite stories that came out of the Great Buffalo Roundup was something that happened to Forsyth. Here is one account:
“The entry of the buffalo into the corral came nearly being accompanied by a regrettable fatality. Mr. Forsyth, an enterprising photographer from Butte, Mont., being anxious to get some photos of the animals in the water, had stationed himself at a point of vantage amidst a clump of trees close to one of the booms in the river where he judged he would be out of path of the oncoming herd. However they chose to take the bank directly below where he was standing, and before he could reach safety they were upon him in a mad, irresistible stampede. How he escaped being trampled to instant death is a miracle which even he cannot realize. He has a recollection of the herd rushing upon him and of having in some way clutched a passing calf which he clung to until it passed under a tree. He then managed to grasp a branch and although he was unable to pull himself up out of danger he was able to keep himself from under the feet of the plunging herd. His dangling legs were bruised and cut by their horns and his clothes were torn to shreds, but he still clung to the limb for life. Twice the herd passed under him as they circled back in an attempt to escape, but fortunately before he became exhausted they rushed into the corral. The Canadian Pacific officials and the riders who knew the location chosen by Forsyth shuddered when they saw the animals rush in there and expected to find his body trampled out of semblance in the clay. Consequently they were rejoiced to find the luckless photographer slightly disfigured, but still hugging his friend the tree in his dishevelled wardrobe. His two costly cameras were trampled to pieces and his opinion of his predicament was summed up in the words, ‘I have had enough buffalo.’”
I actually talked about this incident in this blog post a few years ago. I had at that time matched this newspaper account with what I thought was a photograph depicting the bison herd that trampled him swimming across a river, only moments before he was trampled. I was wrong. I still suspect it may be the same group of bison… but the helpful thing about Forsyth is that when he printed his stereographs, he always put a label on them. Sometimes they were descriptive, sometimes comedic. And so I was absolutely thrilled to bits when I found this stereograph, which is, without a doubt, the stampede that nearly killed him:
“Where Forsyth Lost His Camera and Nearly His Life.” How definitive is that? And to be honest, you can really tell those bison are heading towards the photographer at speed, and are being funneled by that fence and those trees. (Image from the Montana Historical Society.)
I had found this image a little while back, and I was excited enough about that. And then when I was trying to source those two photos for my colleague this past week, I stumbled across this entry in the database, which is a stereograph by Forsyth of a print of a painting, in a picture frame. It definitely piqued my interest!
The photo itself is a bit meh in terms of quality and composition, but critically, it includes the title of the painting and that it’s by Charles Russell… which led me to this beauty:
Just look at that, friends. There’s the buffalo. There’s Forsyth dangling from a tree. There’s his camera smashed on the ground. And check out the fence line on the lefthand side. This artist at the very least saw Forsyth’s photograph of the incident, and heard the tale… or he physically visited the site where it happened. Or both. And the fact that Forsyth took a photograph of the painting, and reproduced it as a stereograph… I may be speculating here, but this genuinely feels to me like a friendship. It’s definite evidence that they knew each other in some way. And I absolutely love the idea of an artist memorializing his friend’s undignified near-death experience in a painting.
The recording of the recent season finale live show episode of the Let’s Find Out podcast that I was on is now live! Check out the show’s blog post here and give it a listen! It was a truly engaging evening with some knowledgeable co-panelists and an incredibly thoughtful audience. There are always so many things that can’t make it into a single talk. The problem for me usually isn’t trying to find something to say, but to narrow down the scope of what I do say, to make it an effective and engaging narrative. In this post, I’m going to share some of my speaking notes, elaborate on them, particularly when it comes to the Canadian national parks that no longer exist. I’ll also share some images (as I said in the show, I recognize that podcasting is an audio medium) that were in my slides, as well as some that didn’t make the initial cut.
I’ve worked at several different historic sites and national parks in Western Canada and it strikes me that even the way Parks Canada is divided into national parks and national historic sites, reinforces this idea that historic sites are where people learn about history, and national parks are where people learn about nature, as if there are no species at risk or conservation concerns at historic sites, or that national areas had no history… which of course erases the history and continued presence of Indigenous peoples in these territories as well. But natural areas have a history! They aren’t unchanging! And they need members of the public to care about them and support them if they are to continue to exist.
I for one love to talk about the history of natural spaces. We often think of national parks today as being relatively static. Banff’s been around since 1885 (or is it 1912, with the Dominion Park Act?), Elk Island since 1906, Wood Buffalo since 1922, Prince Albert since 1928… They’ve existed for generations, and so surely they will continue to exist for generations to come, right? Then you run across maps like this in a pamphlet from 1936 and you suddenly remember that parks need support and upkeep, and they’re not indissoluble. They can cease to be, if people and governments cease to care about them.
Sketch Map Showing Location of National Parks of Canada, June 1935. Reproduced in this 1936 booklet promoting Prince Albert National Park in Saskatchewan.Different versions of this map circulated in promotional material throughout the 1920s – 1940s, with national parks being added – and removed.
I am fascinated by Elk Island’s history, but I am also intrigued by the stories of national parks that no longer exist. Today, national parks are created with the idea of protecting representative samples of ecosystems. Like, protecting a section of taiga or transition zone between boreal forest and aspen parkland. But in the first half of the 20th century, ecology was still in its infancy, and national parks were created with different models in mind. Banff, Jasper, and Waterton Lakes were all founded as “scenic parks”, in which their value was in their outstanding scenery and tourism potential. Elk Island was created along the old “animal park” model. Animal parks were effectively game preserves, created to help build up population of a single, iconic species. Note that Elk Island is the only national park in Canada remaining that was founded originally along the animal park model – it was founded as an elk preserve, but soon became known for its role in bison conservation.
The story of the near-total loss of the buffalo, and the impacts that still echo down to today, is too important and nuanced a story to do justice by telling here. I also think that the story of the Great Buffalo Roundup of 1907-1912 needs to be told in its own full length book. Effectively, it’s important to note that one of the single most important conservation herds of bison, what became known as the Pablo-Allard herd, was founded and protected by Indigenous people for decades, before ultimately being split into different conservation herds, including the ones that formed the basis of the plains bison populations in what is now Canada today.
Bison from the Pablo-Allard herd resting in Lamont near the train station (see trains in background, past fence) before being herded into Elk Island. Image courtesy of Peel’s Prairie Provinces.
The bison from the Pablo-Allard herd were urgently brought North of the Medicine Line, to Elk Park, in 1907 – 1909. Elk Island had a fence, and was near a train station in the town of Lamont (the photo above is in fact the Lamont train station, not Edmonton’s, despite the postcard label). They literally built a fence that stretched from Lamont to the park and herded the bison down that. But Elk Island wasn’t the intended final destination of these bison… a new animal park had made. The problem was they were in such a rush to acquire the bison that the fences weren’t ready until 1909.
Buffalo National Park only existed for about 30 years, from 1909-1939 and it faced many challenges. It was a victim of its own success. In the absence of predators bison populations increase by about 20% every year. The math adds up very quickly. By the mid-1920s, bison populations at Wainwright peaked at nearly 9000 individuals, in an area that was estimated to have a carrying capacity of only about 5,000 bison. And that’s not counting the elk, deer, and pronghorn! Videos and photos I’ve seen show an overabundance of animal populations. This was a continual concern from 1920 onwards, and an overabundance of caution meant that the problem ballooned with the bison population. Overpopulation led to other problems. The park experienced problems with overgrazing. It was marginal land in the first place. Then there were disease and parasites – tuberculosis in bison, liver fluke in other ungulates on the land.
This photo of an RCMP officer standing in a buffalo robe coat in front of Parliament Hill was taken between 1955 and 1963. The hide from this coat almost certainly came from either Elk Island or Buffalo National Parks. Image courtesy of Library and Archives Canada.
The staff of Buffalo National Park tried several different methods of population control. There was culling. They had an abattoir on site selling meat and hides – including for RCMP winter uniforms. Elk Island had the same. But slaughter was unpopular even at the time! Even though culling took place at Buffalo National, it was never going to be a popular solution. Remember, the loss of the great bison herds was only a generation before – and was effectively still within living memory of some folks. Even though bison were hyper-abundant at Wainwright, they were still near-extinction elsewhere – there were only a handful of conservation herds. There were live transfers. For instance, they sent over 6,000 young plains bison at great expense to Wood Buffalo National Park. Those problems resonating still decades later, with hybridization between the two sub-species and introduced diseases.
But ultimately, what did it in was a lack of continued federal funding/interest. We funded the creation of the national park, we bought the buffalo and brought them there… what more do you want? Remember, the last decade the park was in operation was during the Great Depression – the Dominion government was prioritizing spending on other things, and every potential solution to the overpopulation problem came with a cost.
Ultimately the park was shut down in 1939, used for military training during the war, and was converted to a military base in 1947. In fact, you can visit a small display herd of bison, which they re-acquired from Elk Island in the 1980s. After the live show, I spoke with a fellow from the audience who said he was in the military and has done training maneuvers at Wainwright, and that the spot where the abattoir once was is still a reference point on a map, and that it’s some sort of pit. He’d always wondered why there had been an abattoir on site! I had heard from documentary maker Mike Wivell (who interviewed me for a bison history documentary he’s making) that you can still find the original park gates in Wainwright. I’d visited in the last winter with my dad and wasn’t able to find them. My brother and father persevered though and the next time they went to Wainwright deer hunting, they managed to track the gates down and sent me a photograph. They’d been moved but are still very much there.
Screenshot of clip from the Great Buffalo Saga (a 1985 National Film Board documentary) showing the original Buffalo National Park gates. The old Buffalo National Park gates as they stood on the grounds of CFB Wainwright in winter 2022-23. Photo courtesy of Ian and Alan Markewicz.
Buffalo National Park is only the most well-documented of these “lost” national parks. There were others, even shorter lived. There were also national park reserves which ultimately didn’t pan out into national parks. Nemiskam and Wawaskesy National Parks were created as very small animal parks, again, to protect iconic species, in this case, the pronghorn. Nemiskam was fenced in a very similar way to Elk Island, with the pronghorn being herded into a fenced area and the final side being built afterwards to trap them in. They were in southern Alberta – within driving distance of Medicine Hat.
(Side note: I don’t know much about Wawaskesy, but I am intrigued by the fact that its name clearly shares an origin with the community I now live in, in Saskatchewan: Waskesiu Lake, which gets its name from the Cree word “wâwâskesiw”, meaning elk. I thought it was an elk preserve, but no, it’s always listed as being a preserve for pronghorn.)
There was a third one that I’ve read about in old promotional material, called Menissawok National Park in Saskatchewan but it’s unclear if it went anywhere. I’ve found newspaper accounts from the 1910s, 1920s, and 1930s about Nemiskam and Wawaskesy but they were very small, had only a handful of staff, and seemed to drop out of existence after the 1930s. They’re just quietly removed from tourism promotional material by the late 1930s, early 1940s. More research is needed, but I think it was a matter of them not particularly thriving in terms of tourism… and ultimately, they were good at improving the stability of pronghorn populations! Some pronghorn would reportedly escape every year, as the snow grew deep. Was a fence even needed anymore? This is me speculating because I have so few accounts of what it was like to visit or work in these tiny ephemeral national parks. It’s interesting to me, too, to contemplate the idea that these pronghorn parks ultimately may have no longer needed to exist because the pronghorn could go free. Letting “surplus” bison from Buffalo National Park roam free outside of the park fences never seemed to be considered an option. There is a long history of there being resistance in North America to free-ranging bison; the “social carrying capacity” is generally much smaller than the actual ecological carrying capacity.
At this time, Elk Island National Park was growing in size, acquiring additional land as the bison and elk populations grew. In 1947, it acquired what was called at the time the “isolation area” south of highway 16, which is now the wood bison area of the park – Elk Island got a population of wood bison in the 1960s from Wood Buffalo National Park. The federal and Alberta provincial governments negotiated after the Second World War to acquire this land for Elk Island. But in exchange, the federal government shrank Waterton Lakes National Park – which was quite small at the time – and agreed to abolish Buffalo and Nemiskam National Parks. Effectively, due to the Alberta Natural Resources Act, lands that were once national parks reverted to the province. Swapping land between federal departments and government departments seemed fairly common in the 1910s, 1920s and 1930s, and national parks grew, shrank, or ceased to exist.
What lessons were learned? I find it interesting to compare the trajectories of Elk Island and Buffalo National Parks. They struggled with the same challenges and the same wildlife, and implemented some of the same solutions. Elk Island also had an abattoir. Yes, they practiced culling. Yes, they even raised hay to supplement bison feed… park staff still refer to the bison loop area as “the hay meadows” though it’s since been restored to native prairie grasslands. When it came to population and disease control, Elk Island succeeded, after concerted effort, to get disease and population issues under control, and since the 1970s has been considered disease free. Elk Island has since that time controlled its population of elk and bison largely through live transfers. That’s why you hear about places like Banff, Waterton, and Grasslands National Parks getting bison from Elk Island. If you’ve seen a bison elsewhere in Canada, odds are its ancestors passed through Elk Island… except for, oddly, Riding Mountain National Park in Manitoba, which got its bison directly from Buffalo National Park originally. But effectively, Elk Island benefitted from learning from the mistakes made at Buffalo National Park. We’ve learned so much about conservation, carrying capacity, disease control, and ecosystem monitoring and management since the 1920s and 1930s. Elk Island struggles with its identity but in many ways is still an animal park model – primarily protecting plains and wood bison… though there are significant elk, moose, and migratory bird populations. I think it recent years it’s embraced its identity as the seed conservation herd for plains and wood bison in Canada, and has helped establish new, healthy bison populations across the continent.
National Parks aren’t unchanging, fixed landscapes. They do require human intervention, funding, and care – they can grow, they can shrink, or they can cease to exist. National Parks exist because people value these places.
Hart, E.J. (Ted). J.B. Harkin: Father of Canada’s National Parks. Edmonton, AB: University of Alberta Press, 2010.
Lothian, W.F. A History of Canada’s National Parks. Ottawa, ON: Parks Canada, 1976 – 1981. (Full text of his work available online at the link provided.) Note that Lothian was a longtime employee of the national parks. It’s also fascinating that he spoke of individual national park histories under headers specifically dedicated to those parks, but didn’t have specific sections on Buffalo National Park or Nemiskam… though he did discuss them as was relevant in the history of Elk Island, for instance.
Markewicz, Lauren. Like Distant Thunder: Canada’s Bison Conservation Story. (Elk Island National Park, Alberta: Parks Canada, 2017. (Full text available on Elk Island National Park’s website. Print copies also available for sale at Parks Canada sites with bison under the title Through the Storm: Canada’s Bison Conservation Story.)
McKennirey, Michael. The Great Buffalo Saga. National Film Board, 1985. This documentary interviews former park staff from Buffalo National Park and shows clips of Buffalo National Park as well as a wood bison transfer from Elk Island to a northern First Nations community in the early 1980s. (Full documentary viewable on the NFB’s website and Youtube channel.)
Hello everyone! Do you have plans for Thursday September 21st, 2023? Why not join us for an interesting evening for nature nerds and history afficionados alike? I’ve been invited to be a part of a panel for a podcast live show. The Let’s Find Out podcast is a podcast that explores the ins and outs of the history of the City of Edmonton, driven by questions from community members. The latest season has been all about parks and natural spaces in and around the city.
I’m going to be speaking about the foundation of Elk Island National Park, over 100 years ago, and speaking of other national parks in Alberta whose names may be less familiar to you… How about some foreshadowing, with this promotional material from the 1930s?
One of my favourite questions is “how do we know what we know?” This fascinates me both as a historian and as an environmental educator. I love seeing range maps for different species. I really enjoy using iNaturalist, and clicking on the profile of a species to see where else other users have logged seeing them. But how did people, historically, get a sense of the range of migratory animals like many bird species? That’s where bird banding comes in.
Bird bands are little metal bands attached around the legs of captured birds. They include text about the bird and where it was banded, and usually direct the finder to send in the band along with information on where the bird was found. They can create discrete data points. Birds first started to be banded in this way in Europe in the 1890s and a decade or two later in North America.
Jack Miner was famous in his day for his bird sanctuary and bird banding projects. He particularly specialized in Canada Geese, which he held as being morally upright (contrasted with predatory birds of prey, which he characterized as villainous and cannibalistic). He has been quoted as saying, “To know the Canada goose is to love him forever. You cannot show me any of his actions that one need be ashamed of, not one.”
Miner certainly anthropomorphized animals and spent many years working to reduce the populations of birds of prey. These were early years in conservation work and different conservation philosophies abounded. Jack Miner in particular very much ascribed to the Christian view that God had placed the animals on the Earth for “Man’s” use. He also didn’t believe in the balance of nature, but that humans should be the ultimate arbiters of which animals should be protected, and which killed, based on their usefulness to humans. He did have some conflict with government scientists who were working to standardize bird banding in the 1920s, as he felt it was important to include Christian messages on his bands.
Images of his bird bands, from an article on “Jack Miner’s Bird Missionaries.” Courtesy of Peel’s Prairie Provinces.
Jack Miner’s ideas were very influential, and he drew attention to the importance of migratory birds like Canada Geese. In 37 years of bird banding, he did gather useful data on the length of the lives of waterfowl and even crows, their migration routes, and migration seasons. He was recognized in his lifetime, receiving the Order of the British Empire for his contribution to conservation. He was very well-known for managing a bird sanctuary in which he baited in Canada Geese by the hundreds, and even thousands, every year. He apparently also kept pet deer?
Jack Miner in his old age alongside pet white tailed deer. Courtesy of Peel’s Prairie Provinces.
Tina Loo has a fascinating essay on Miner’s messy and conflicting role in early scientific bird conservation in Canada in the 1920s through 1940s in her book States of Nature: Conserving Canada’s Wildlife in the Twentieth Century. I definitely recommend it as a good starting point to learn more about this man and his work! In the meantime, I would like to share with you a selection of fascinating and truly delightful photographs of Jack Miner and his geese.
Over the last several months, I’ve been working my way through Christopher De Hamel’s book Meetings with Remarkable Manuscripts: Twelve Journeys into the Medieval World, and I just finished reading the final chapter today. I’m not a medievalist – I’ve often found books on medieval history that I’ve been exposed to are very focused on warfare, religion, and the history of “Great” men, which are fine topics of study but of less interest to me. (I recognize that there are other focusses of medieval scholarship but as I haven’t made a particular study of this time period I’m less aware of others – please feel free to recommend books / works you think I’d like!) As such, my understanding of the time period was sort of “flattened”, in that I couldn’t really distinguish much between the early and late medieval periods, aside from a general sense of changing fashions and art styles, and a knowledge that there was a lot of wars and politicking.
However, de Hamel’s book really gets at the heart of what I find particularly interesting about any period of history: the lived experience of people, and what the materiality of surviving artifacts can tell us about their lives. This book does describe the contents of the manuscripts under discussion (dating from the late sixth century Gospels of St. Augustine to the Spinola Hours from nearly a thousand years later, 1515-1520), but more than that, the author delves into amazing detail about what we can learn about the medieval world and its people from the materiality of these books. What can we learn about the book from the “hand” that wrote it – and what can we determine about their identity? What about little oxidized pinpricks that indicate a long since removed metal clasp? In what ways were books made in different regions made unique by the materials available and the local education of their makers, and in what ways were these far-flung places actually connected, by culture, education, or traded goods? What details can we glean that tell us a bit about the books history: where it was made, why it was made, and where it’s been for the last 1,000 years before it popped up again unexpectedly in the mid-1800s? The way he describes the minutia, it very much is a form of historic detective work.
I also really enjoyed how the author always described the experience of seeing the book in the archive where it rests today. This is a researcher who has consulted so many manuscripts over his life time things like the feel and weight of the parchment, the smell of the book, and the nuances of the writing, ping things in his brain, where he can draw connections to texts he consulted decades before. As he says on multiple occasions in the book, you don’t really get a sense of some of what he’s describing from a facsimile or a photograph, but he does his best to try. I really felt like I was walking along with him as he visited these archives, sitting beside him at the consultation table and leaning over his shoulder as he pointed out nifty details.
I want to share a few choice passages with you today that really spoke to me and made me want to learn more. I hope that you too pick up a copy of this book and delve into the world of medieval manuscripts!
On the Book of Kells (late eighth century): “Newcomers to manuscripts sometimes ask what such books tell us about the societies that created them. At one level, these Gospel Books describe nothing, for they are not local chronicles but standard Latin translations of religious texts from far away. At the same time, this is itself extraordinarily revealing about Ireland. No one knows how literacy and Christianity had first reached the islands of Ireland, possibly through North Africa. This was clearly no primitive backwater but a civilization which could now read Latin, although never occupied by the Romans, and which was somehow familiar with texts and artistic designs which have unambiguous parallels in the Coptic and Greek churches, such as carpet pages and Canon tables. Although the Book of Kells itself is as uniquely Irish as anything imaginable, it is a Mediterranean text and the pigments used in making it include orpiment, a yellow made from arsenic sulphide, exported from Italy, where it is found in volcanoes. There are clearly lines of trade and communication unknown to us.”(124-5)
On the Morgan Beatus (mid-tenth century): “The Morgan Beatus is written in the script known to paleographers as Visgothic minuscule. To explain it, we need to go back to the origin of Latin writing in ancient Rome. There were two distinct classes of script common in Roman antiquity. The first of these were high-grade display capitals, such as the letters ‘S.P.Q.R.’ on classical monuments, easily legible to us, and rustic capitals in books, as imitated in the Leiden Aratea. At the other end of the scale were rapid cursive hands – ‘joined-up writing’ as children call it – used on papyrus for administrative documents. At the simplest level – it was a bit more complex in reality – Roman capitals evolved over the centuries into unicals, and eventually (through subtle and gradual mutations, as in genetics) descended into modern European letter forms, including those used in this book. The cursive, however, was exported outwards with imperial bureaucracy into the Roman provinces, where it bred independently into the many local variants of handwriting, such as the strange-looking spidery Merovingian minuscules in France, Alemannic miniscule in western Germany, and so on. These were then swept away by Charlemagne in the early ninth century in a deliberate programme of standardization of script throughout his vast dominions, substituting the famous ‘Caroligian’ or ‘Caroline’ minuscule. Only on the outer fringes of Europe, beyond the reach of Carolingian authority, the tenacious descendants of Roman cursive managed to live on, like prehistoric animals still surviving in some fictional valley isolated from the outside world. The best-known of these living fossils are Beneventan minuscule in southern Italy and up to the extreme fringes of the eastern coast as far as Croatia, and Visgothic minuscule in much of Spain and Portugal. The fact that such scripts endured, against the trend, even into the eleventh and twelfth centuries, tells us a great deal about the cultural frontiers of contemporary politics.
“Visgothic minuscule, which has nothing to do with the illiterate tribal Visgoths other than a shared association with pre-Muslim Iberia, is beautiful and calligraphic and exasperatingly difficult to read. It is filled with flowing ligatures inherited from Roman cursive, such as the joined ‘e’ and ‘r’ resembling a single letter. The lower case ‘a’ is open-topped like ‘u’, and ‘s’ looks like ‘r’, and ‘t’ rather like a modern ‘a’. Reading Visgothic reminds me of being a child on the first days of the summer holidays. One would scamper painfully in bare feet across the road and over pebbles on the beach, feigning ease and non-chalance; by the very end of the holiday, it was truthfully no hardship at all. Early next summer it was agony all over again. Stare at an impenetrable page of Visgothic minuscule in despair, struggle letter by letter, and by late afternoon, usually just as the library is about to close, it becomes at last surprisingly legible; next morning it is quite unreadable once more. This might explain partly why Beatus had such limited circulation outside early-medieval Spain.”(209-10)
On the Morgan Beatus (mid-tenth century): “The second volume opens on folio 150 with the storia from revelation 11:17-10. The first picture shows the Antichrist – his face vindictively scratched by an outraged reader (long ago, I hope) – chopping the witnesses into nasty blooded pieces…”(218)
Detail of the antichrist with his face scratched out by a reader, from the Morgan Beatus.
On the Morgan Beatus (mid-tenth century): On the art of this manuscript, which has been described by other scholars as unsophisticated, especially compared to pieces like the Book of Kells: The “downright strangeness of the pictures may have had a practical purpose. The monastic method of studying the Scriptures was to read a sentence or two aloud, and then to think about the text word by word, looking slowly for multiple layers of meaning. It was called ‘lectio divina‘. That meditative rumination was itself an act of devotion. If the monk could gaze at the page and memorize it, then this slow pious reflexion could continue in his mind long after the original manuscript had been closed up and put away in its box in the cloisters. Passages of plain script, maybe especially in Visigothic minuscule with little word-division, are difficult to envisage afterwards, but pages with complex illustrations as dramatic and as unsettling as those here are impossible to erase from memory. Their naivety is a benefit. The brilliance of the colour and the startling narrative drama have real value. They served as a mnemonic device to enable reflexion on Revelation to continue among many readers at once, at any time of day or night.”(224)
On the Carmina Burana (first half of the thirteenth century): “Since Latin was the language of international literacy, versus composed in France were just as understandable in London, Cologne, Rome or Salzburg, at least by educated men. When the poems had lost their context so far that they had been reduced to dance songs in which women participated, however, extra verses were sometimes added in the German language. Many of the earliest records of vernacular languages of Europe are associated with women, who were at that time genenerally less Latinate than men. About forty of the love poems of the Carmina Burana have refrains in German, in the same metre as the Latin. These were probably supplied when the songs were used as rounds, with the different languages to be sung simultaneously by male and female voices. About a dozen other poems in the manuscript are partly or entirely in German. This is extremely early in the survival of any vernacular literature. Some German verses in the Carmina Burana are addressed to women, doubtless in the guise of admirers supposing that their suits might be more successful if the lady understood what was being asked of her. Examples are “Süziu vrouw min …”, ‘My sweet woman …’, imploring her to enjoy the darts of Venus, and “Selich wip, vil süziz wip …”, ‘Lovely lady, most sweet lady …’, describing how the writer has sent her a love letter. Others are set in the voices of women themselves, addressed to men. There is a charming poem on folio 72r in which a woman is whispering to her lover who has secretly stayed all night, “Ich sich den morgen sterne brehen …” (‘I see the morning star breaking …’), urging him to slip away without being seen. . . . In one famous five-line verse in German in the Carmina Burana the protagonist gladly offers to sacrifice the wealth of the entire world to lie in bliss in the arms of the queen of England. In fact, in the manuscript itself, the scribe originally wrote ‘king of England’ – “chunich van engellant” – which was crossed out and later altered to ‘the queen’ (“diu chunegin”). It seems to be in reality to make better sense as the wish of a woman, speaking German. The formidable Eleanor of Aquitaine (c. 1122-1204), queen of England 1154-89, was an unlikely object of male fantasy, but her son, the dashing Richard the Lionheart, was unmarried and nearby, a prisoner in Austria in 1192-4. This would furnish a plausible date and general locality for the composition of the German text. “It is generally accepted that the manuscript of the Carmina Burana was not compiled at Benediktbeuern itself, but probably somewhere further south in what is now Austria, then part of greater Bavaria. The script has pronounced Italianate features, as often in Austrian books, and the smooth pages have a southern feel to the touch, unlike the more suede-like texture of German parchment. (This is a judgement impossible to make from a photograph, or while wearing gloves.)” (367-8)
On the Hours of Jeanne de Navarre(second quarter of the fourteenth century): “The original owner, however, was not a friar or nun, and her identity is not in doubt. About twenty margins include little vignettes of a queen kneeling in prayer, wearing a gold crown and a cloak lined with ermine, sometimes with a manuscript open in front of her. Elsewhere she kneels in the illuminated initials. Sometimes she appears within miniatures themselves, witnessing first-hand the Scourging of Christ and venerating the Virgin and Child in their actual presence. Many of the prayers in the text are adapted for exclusive use by a woman, as we can tell from words that have gender-specific endings in Latin. Examples are “… ut michi indigne peccatrici ancille tue” (‘to me your unworthy sinful servant,’ all feminine forms), “… concede michi famule tue” (‘grant me your servant’, where a male petitioner would have been “famulo tuo”), and the prayer upon receiving Communion, “Domine non sum digna …” (‘Lord, I am not worthy …’, the female form of the adjective). By extreme good fortune, the woman is actually named. This is in a prayer to the Virgin Mary which happens to include a plea to ‘intercede for me, your servant, Johanna, queen of Navarre’, or, in the original, “ut intercedas pro me ancilla tua Johanna navarre regina”. These precious words are on folio 151v, easy to overlook in the middle of a page of text.”(391)
On visiting the Visconti Semideus(c. 1438) in St. Petersburg, which is all about tactics of medieval warfare: “The first hurdle is the immensely complex application for a Russia visa, for which one has to list, among many other things, every school and university attended and every job one has ever had, with dates and contact names and telephone numbers, and every country one has visited in the previous ten years, with dates. Any involvement with politics or armed conflict, at any period of one’s life, has to be declared. There are clearly issues that are sensitive. For the stated purpose of my purported visit to Russia, I toyed for a moment with writing ‘gaining access to government department to inspect manual on armaments and military strategy’ but instead I put ‘tourism.'”(472-3)
On the Visconti Semideus(c. 1438): “The text describes how to advance on the city, with God’s help, bearing shields and catapults and bringing constructions to be moved up against the walls, and what I take to mean bombards or cannons (literally ‘roaring bronze’), with flamethrowers, slinging machines, and other instruments of war. Many terms for siege machinery are listed – “tormentis, fundibulis, scorpiis” and others: my little Latin dictionary simply defines each one as ‘catapult’ but there are evidently subtle differences known to military specialists.”(491)
References
De Hamel, Christopher. Meetings with Remarkable Manuscripts: Twelve Journeys into the Medieval World. New York, NY: Penguin Press, 2016.
Many libraries and archives seem to have made available many of the manuscripts written about by De Hamel in his book. If any of the works described here or in his book intrigue you, go snooping on their website. Be prepared to go down a rabbit hole of zooming in on high resolution scans of these books!
Earlier this week I was up early (5:45am or so) and I was able to watch the most amazing aurora borealis event I’d ever had the chance to witness. In person, they largely looked like grey-green wispy clouds with the occasional hint of purple or blue, but the colours really came out in the photos. I managed to take a few really decent photos with my phone on night mode, either with me bracing my arm against a tree or a picnic table for stability, or with a 5-second delay and then placed flat on a picnic table to be completely stable.
This display of course got my mind thinking about historical accounts of aurorae. I popped over to Peel’s Prairie Provinces, which has a large selection of entirely digitized, full text searchable, small town newspapers from what are now Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba, to see how people described encountering the aurora borealis generations ago. Apparently, the feeling of people saying “oh my gosh it was amazing, let me describe it in detail” to those who slept right through amazing light shows is a traditional response.
AURORAL DISPLAY The gorgeous display on Saturday evening of the beautiful aurora borealis seen in this district, is one which, though not often witnessed, will never be forgotten by the happy beholder. The electric storm (for such it is known by many) began about ten o’clock, and it seemed to centre in our Zenith, and then expand and radiate out from this centre to all the points of the compass, in ever changing shades and forms. There were displayed in the most beautiful and grotesque manner all the colours and shades of the rainbow. It was really such a profusion and richness of beauty and colouring which no wealth could purchase and no poet adequately describe, so in our humility, we will leave it to our considerate readers to imagine all the attractiveness of the scene which our poor pen has left untold.
The Aurora It is very seldom that the Aurora, or Northern Lights, look more splendid than they did yesterday evening just after darkness had set in. The sight was a magnificent one, the lights shooting far to the south of the zenith(?), and being all colors from a deep rose to a pure white. They shifted and changed their position constantly, at times only illuminating a portion of the heavens, at others spreading all over it. The sight was witnessed by numbers of our citizens, and the general opinion seems to have been that it is rarely – even in this district where the sight is not an uncommon one – the lights show out as magnificently as they did last night.
SPLENDID NORTHERN LIGHTS Some Recent Displays of Aurora Borealis in the Far Northwest The northern lights have been uncommonly fine and bright at Edmonton, N.W.T., for some weeks and the wise ones say that we shall have a long, sharp winter. Others hold that the aurora dances only when a cold spell is breaking up in the north and that we may expect mild weather so long as they are active. But whether the prophets say warm or cold, the people are sawing wood just the same and are not taking any chances. Last winter the mercury dropped to 40o below zero and the Edmontonians don’t propose to be left out in the cold in consequence of any northern lights. The other night there was a remarkable outburst of polar lights that intensified until at 2 o’clock next morning, more than half of the sky was filled with them. A peculiarity of this display was that the arch was lifted so high and tilted, on our side of the earth, so far southward that it was seen not to be an arch but an immense circle, girdling the northern hemisphere, with its axis somewhere along the Mackenzie. In other words, the electrical core or magnetic pole, seemed to have shifted down until it was comparatively near us. . . . After keeping its place in mid-heaven for a time the band broke into clouds and receded toward the north. A few nights ago an uncommonly brilliant display occurred, the celestial fireworks being visible during sunset. They lasted through the night and on the following evening were still there, showing themselves before the west was dark. Where the rays bunched themselves together the light was clearly intensified, and the still forest stood out against it in black silhouette. These rays frequently shot to the zenith and as they rolled together, formed beams of throbbing green light like that of the early gloaming in point of luminosity. It suggested indeed that the spear of Odin and the clubs of the frost giants were brandished above the domes of Walhalla in despair at the coming of Goetterdaemmerung; and, as if the fires of mundane destruction were alight already, there was a blood red glow at the northern horizon, a glare(?) as if the earth’s crust had been lifted out, and the boiling lava was surging out. For a time during the display portions of a double arch were seen, two segments of pale fire pushing out beneath the main arch, and afterward being absorbed by it. Frequently the lights assumed the form of drapery, a curtain thousands of miles long, and hundreds of miles high, spangled with stars, its green and blue and golden fringes flapping against the earth as it billowed(?) and tossed and rolled from side to side in the strain of gales blowing out of space, a loosened sail of the earth ship bounding – whither?
Beautiful Display of Aurora Borealis The heavens were illuminated last night with the most beautiful display of the aurora borealis it has ever been our experience to witness. About 9.30 in the northwestern sky appeared to mirror an immense fire and the apparent reflection cast a rich red hue over the heavens. This changed into the old fashioned northern lights with shooting rays from west to east. For a time the sky appeared to have cleared, but it was at 11.30 that the display reached its prettiest. At that time the whole sky was enveloped in a sea of loveliness which beggars description. From every corner of the horizon it was covered with a curtain that would make Joseph’s coat fade into insignificance. These flimsy curtain-like rays appeared to be gathered up in the centre immediately overhead and held by a large rosette of flaming red. From the centre the red faded into a soft cerise which, mingled with all the colors of the rainbow, created a setting which stood out as if defying the most skilled artist to paint anything half so beautiful. The effect was wonderful and those who did not see it missed a rare sight.
NORTHERN LIGHTS FINEST SEEN HERE Bishop Newnham Says Aurora Display Brightest Since 1870 in West The northern lights witnessed in Edmonton last Thursday evening played havoc with the telegraphic wires all over Canada and resulted in big delay[s] in telegraphic business according to city telegraphic men. The display was one of the finest ever witnessed in the west. Bishop Newnham of Prince Albert, who is a great student of this phenomenon, says it was the most striking that he has ever seen. In a statement to the Canadian Press he says: ‘The only time I have seen anything like it was in 1870, when, during the Franco-Prussian war, Paris was besieged by the Germans. I [saw] that from London, England, and many people were under the impression that Paris was being burned.’ Bishop Newnham says that the aurora Thursday night was of a bright red color similar to the reflection of a gigantic fire. The news dispatches indicated that the aurora was visible in England and probably aided a German aerial raid.
Déjeuner dans le trou de la Sorcière (Forêt noire)/ Breakfast in the Witch Hole (Black Forest), a print from 1854. Image from Gallica.
One of the books that’s been on my shelf for a while is Jennifer Westwood and Jacqueline Simpson’s hefty work The Lore of the Land: A Guide to England’s Legends, from Spring-Heeled Jack to the Witches of Warboys. It’s almost an encyclopedia of folklore from across England, peppered with references to the primary material from which they draw these little snippets of lore. Here are a few I thought you would appreciate, writing this as I am on All Hallow’s Eve:
Knutsford, Cheshire: There are two explanations for the name of this town, both mentioned by its historian, Henry Green, in the 1850s. One is that there was once an old woman who sold nuts for her living, and when dying asked to be buried with a bag of them under her head. This was done, but she found this pillow so uncomfortable that, after turning over in her coffin and finding the other side no better, she one night clambered out of her grave, emptied the bag, cracked all the nuts against her gravestone, and ate them – all but one, which she dropped without realizing it. She then refolded the bag to use as a pillow, got back into her coffin, and has slept there peacefully ever since. But a fine hazel sprouted from the nut she dropped on her grave. Henry Green, telling this tale in 1859, says that there really had been a tree growing from a grave here; by the time he was writing only its shattered stem remained, but he himself had once plucked a leaf from its branches, which was seen as ‘an undeniable witness’ that all this was true.(81)
Crowcombe, Somerset: It was believed in Somerset (as in several other regions) that anyone who kept watch in a church porch at midnight on Midsummer Eve or Halloween would see the wraiths of all those fated to die in the parish in the coming year entering the church for their own funeral service. (641)
Pinkney Park, Wiltshire: In a niche overlooking the main staircase of this house . . . there is a skull, thought to be that of a woman; traditions about it were told to the local writer Kathleen Wiltshire in the 1970s. There are also marks said to be irremoveable bloodstains on the floor of one room, and a woman’s handprint on the door of another; according to the traditions, the story behind all that is two sisters in the family loved the same man, so one murdered the other, out of jealousy. . . . the skull is said to have been there for centuries, despite many attempts to remove, smash, or burn it, from which it invariably returns unharmed, as is the normal case with stories of this type. Legend used also to claim that it would fall to dust of its own accord when the last Pinkney died and the house and estate passed into other ownership, but the property did in fact change hands several generations ago, without affecting the skull at all.(792)
Black Heddon, Northumberland: M.A. Richardson’s Table Book (1842-5) includes an account, sent him by Robert Robertson of Sunderland, of the haunting sixty or seventy years previously of Black Heddon, near Stamfordham, by a supernatural being known as ‘Silky’ from her predilection for appearing dressed in silk: “Many a time, when any of the more timorous of the community had a night journey to perform, have they unawares and invisibly been dogged and watched, by this spectral tormentor, who at the dreariest part of the road. . . would suddenly break forth in dazzling splendour. If the person happened to be on horseback . . . she would unexpectedly seat herself behind, ‘rattling in her silks.’ There, after enjoying a comfortable ride; with instantaneous abruptness, she would. . . dissolve away . . . leaving the bewildered horseman in blank amazement.” At Belsay, a few miles from Black Heddon, there was a crag under the shadows of whose trees Silky loved to wander at night. At the bottom of the crag was a waterfall, over which an ancient tree spread its arms, amid which Silky had a rough chair, where she used to sit, rocked by the wind. Sir Charles M.L Monck, of Belsay Castle, had carefully preserved this tree, still called ‘Silky’s seat.’ Horses were sensitive to Silky’s presence and she seemed to take pleasure in stopping them in their tracks, so that no manner of brute force could get them moving. The only remedy was ‘magic-dispelling witchwood’ (rowan, mountain ash). . . . Silky is described as ‘wayward and capricious.’ Like many bogeys, she revelled in surprise. Women who cleaned their houses on Saturday night, ready for the Sabbath, would find them next morning turned upside-down, but, if the house had been left untidy, Silky would put it straight. Eventually, she abruptly disappeared. People had long surmised that she must be the restless ghost of someone who had died before disclosing the whereabouts of her treasure. Supposedly, about this time, a servant, alone in one of the rooms of a house at Black Heddon, was terrified by the ceiling giving way, ‘and from it there dropt, with a prodigious clash, something quite black, shapeless and uncouth.’ The servant fled to her mistress screaming at the top of her voice, ‘The deevil’s in the house! The deevil’s in the house! He’s come through the ceiling!’ IT was some time before anyone dared to look, but finally, the mistress, stouter-hearted than the rest, ventured into the room and found there a great dog or calf’s skin – filled with gold. After this, Silky was never more heard or seen. (549-50)
Canewdon, Essex: Canewdon was once notorious for its witches, a reputation linked with the tall tower of Canewdon church, of which, says Philip Benton in his History of Rochford Hundred (1867), ‘A tradition exists, and is believed by many, that so long as this steeple exists, there will always remain six witches in Canewdon.
In the 1920s, it was likewise said that there were always six witches – three in silk and three in cotton (meaning three well-to-do- and three working women). Charlotte Mason, writing in 1928, says an old man then living in Rayleigh told her that one was supposed to be the parson’s wife, and another the wife of the butcher. He said that a Canewdon girl who had gone to keep house for his uncle at Woodham Ferrers was also one of the witches, and his uncle knew no peace after her coming there ‘for nothing in the house would keep still.’ (He is referring to the witch’s power of moving objects by telekinesis . . .) It was also claimed that a stone fell out of the church wall every time a Canewdon witch died. . . .
A well-known procedure for identifying the culprit when witchcraft was suspected was by heating a witch-bottle containing the victim’s urine and sometimes nail-clippings, ordinary nails, pins, and other items. Eric Maple, writing in Folklore in 1960, puts the proverbial number of Canewdon witches at seven, and says that an old woman told him she was present as a girl at one such ceremony.
. . . . a witch who stole a bell from Latchingdon church, on the other side of the river, tried to bring it back in a washtub, using feathers as oars. She was seen by a waterman, but she bewitched him into forgetting what he had seen by saying, ‘You will speak of it when you think of it.’ It was not until years later, when he heard the bells toll for the funeral of the witch, that he remembered. (251)
Edmondthorpe, Leicestershire: In the parish church of St Michael is the tomb of Sir Roger Smith of Edmondthorpe Hall. He died in c.1655 after two marriages, and both his wives are represented in alabaster effigy on the tomb. The left hand of Lady Ann has been broken and the wrist stained a dark red, perhaps by iron rivets used to mend it. The local explanation of the stain, however, is that Lady Ann was a witch who, as was the habit of witches, could turn herself into a cat. Her butler, trying to drive this cat out of the kitchen, struck it with a meat cleaver, wounding it in the paw. When the cat resumed its human form, the wound was plain to see in the corresponding position on the wrist of Lady Ann. At her death, this ‘wounded hand’ also appeared miraculously on her effigy. And that was not all: as the result of this supernatural event, Edmondthorpe Hall gained an ‘indelible bloodstain’. The cat’s blood had fallen on a kitchen flagstone and the stain proved to be ineradicable. At some time between 1918 and 1922, the Countess of Yarborough, then living at the Hall, had the stone taken up because the maids complained that, however much they scrubbed, it would not come clean. The stone was removed to the workshop of J.W. Golling in the main street of Wymondham, Leicestershire, where it became the object of much curiosity. The phenomenon whereby the wound inflicted on her wer-animal is transferred to the witch is known as ‘repercussion’. Many traditional tales of witches hinge on this belief.(419-20)
Potterne, Wiltshire: It is common in folklore to encounter tales about witches turning into hares. A more unusual experience was reported by a young man in the 1920s to the folklore collector B.H. Cunningham, who printed it in 1943. This young man said that when he was courting a Potterne girl he used to take her for a stroll along the lanes every evening after work. They were always followed by an unknown greyhound; he was convinced that this was the girl’s mother, keeping an eye on them. As proof, he told Cunningham how one rainy evening the dog ran ahead of them as they got near the girl’s home, jumped the garden gate, and disappeared; when they reached the house they could see through the kitchen window the mother standing in a tub, washing mud off her legs.(792)
Eaton’s Fall and Winter Mail Order Catalogue, 1918-19, from Library and Archives Canada. (Follow link and zoom in for higher resolution image.)
One thing I’ve been doing this past year is experiment more with my hair. I am inspired by historical hairstyles partially because I enjoy the aesthetic, and partially because I have waist-length hair and the majority of women’s hairstyles prior to the 1920s (and even some popular hairstyles during the 1920s) are designed with my hair length in mind. I have acquired quite the collection of hair sticks but I rely a lot on hair pins and bobby pins. I ran across this page from a mail order catalogue circa 1918-1919, and there are some delightful details – including the fact that some hair pins have largely remained identical in design for the last 100 years.
Other details I’d like to draw your attention to:
Several of the hair nets they advertise were made with actual human hair.
For the false hair additions, they specifically note that for “drab and grey shades”, send in a sample of your own hair and they’ll send the product that’s the closest match.
Apparently it was a popular enough request that they had to explicitly ask customers not to send them “combings” (which I believe are the hair leftover on your hairbrush) to make into new items, that that wasn’t a service they provided. My understanding is that people in the Victorian and Edwardian eras would often make their own hair pads or hair “rats” (to bulk out their hair and comb their existing hair overtop) from their own discarded hair. I wonder if there were any companies that made them professionally with the customer’s own hair?
For that matter, now I want to know more about the industry that must have existed around selling your own hair to companies who would make products like this, considering the number of items on this page that advertise as being made of real human hair! I worry if I dig even a bit deeper I’ll uncover something horrific about poverty and poor women selling their hair, though. That would track for the period.
I also have to wonder how “natural” the fake beards and toupees actually looked in real life.
I always seem to find the best gems while looking for something else. I was delighted to stumble across this 1919 promotional video about national parks in Canada on Library and Archive Canada’s youtube channel. Let’s take a closer look!
One thing that a lot of folks don’t realize is that national parks can in fact cease to exist. They need the support of visitors, staff, and federal funding continuously over time. This video shows shots of the now-defunct Buffalo National Park (1909 – 1939) in Alberta. After being decommissioned the land was passed to a different federal department and became Canadian Forces Base Wainright. (For a deep dive into the history of Buffalo National Park, check out Jennifer Brower’s book Lost Tracks. You can follow that link to download a free PDF of the book on Athabasca University Press’s website.)
(Another “lost” national park I want to know more about is Nemiskam Antelope Park, which only existed for about two decades in southern Alberta and was meant as an “animal park” to protect pronghorn. There were others, including Menissawok and Wawaskesy national parks, all in the prairie provinces, all defunct by the end of the 1940s.)
Anyway, it’s interesting to see film footage of the bison herds they had in Buffalo National Park, and a mention of supplementing the food they could forage in the winter with hay. That had to happen in part because of the limited range and overpopulation issues that ended up greatly contributing to it being shut down in the late 1930s. It’s also why there are now wood / plains bison hybrids up in Wood Buffalo National Park today – they sent over 6000 plains bison from Buffalo National Park up to Wood Buffalo National Park in 1922 to try to deal with the overpopulation issue without slaughtering a species that had so recently come back from the brink of extinction. So that one little detail hints at so much to come!
The video also shows yaks, and yak hybrids. Brower talks about these animals – it was a part of a series of experiments the federal government ran at the time. The idea was that yaks were in the middle of a continuum of evolution between “primitive” buffalo and “civilized” domestic cattle, and so by trying to hybridize bison and yaks they could see about jump starting evolution. The park staff also experimented with hybridizing bison and domestic cattle, creating “catalo”. Overpopulation and close encounters with yaks and cows are likely the ways that the plains bison became infected with cattle diseases such as bovine tuberculosis.
A sampling of postcards of yaks, yak/bison hybrids, and cattalo at Buffalo National Park. Courtesy of Peel’s Prairie Provinces.
There’s also a shot of a warden feeding some affectionate female elk and I have to wonder if it’s the same warden as in this postcard from Buffalo National Park in 1920?
The video at that point moves on to Jasper National Park, which does in fact still exist. It’s interesting that some of the “must see” places highlighted in the video are still highlights of the park today: the beautiful administration building (now their visitor centre I believe?), Maligne Canyon, and Mount Edith Cavell. One interesting detail is that that section both begins with a shot of the train station and ends with a shot of a train. At that time, Jasper and Banff were mainly accessed by rail. I don’t believe reliable roads where built from Edmonton and Calgary until some time in the 1920s.
Who else is fantasizing about getting away from it all and running away to the mountains? I’m lucky in that I live in a national park (though in the stereotypically unmountainous province of Saskatchewan) so I have been spending a lot of time hiking, snowshoeing, and cross-country skiing, but there’s something about those mountains that are calling me. I’m sure to visit once travel becomes advisable once more! In the meantime, I’m doing historical background research on female artists and mountaineers active in the Canadian Rockies about a century ago, to support the Rockies Repeat art project and documentary. I’m trying not to get too rosy-eyed and nostalgic over the aesthetics and experience of being a tourist in the mountains in the early decades of the 20th century, because it wasn’t without its issues (not the least of which was an Imperial mindset and casual racism), but the enthusiasm that these men and women embraced the outdoor lifestyle is delightful.
In my archival investigations, I ran across this great souvenir newspaper from one of the first meetings of the Alpine Club of Canada, in 1907, and I was charmed by some of the very relatable humour about camp life. Here are a few of my favourite elements:
FASHION NOTES The best kind of gloves to use when climbing are those belonging to your friend. For hot-headed individuals, hats with holes throughout the crown are advised by our leading medical authorities. Patchwork is rapidly growing in Dame Fashion’s favor. The crazier the better. A great variety of shades are popular for the complexion, but perhaps the favorite is crushed strawberry. INTERIOR DECORATIONS The bare appearance of the ordinary tent-pole may be relieved by graceful drapings of knickers, sheets, hose, blouses, etc. In ordinary cases a large number of such garments are required to produce the most artistic effect. The most handsome mantel drapings are composed of puttees [leg wrappings], preferably wet, which should be festooned at suitable intervals from the roof of the tent. Graceful hanging pots may be made by tying ordinary climbing boots together and suspending them from any desirable point. Any plant may be grown in these, but the cactus is said to thrive best.
PERSONALS
A gentleman of the quill called at one of the ladies’ tents early on Wednesday morning, greatly to their consternation. He was soon after promptly killed and his body thrown in the river. It is understood his name was Mr. Pork. U. Pine, of Moraine Lake.
WOMAN’S PAGE By Lady Paradise
Dear Lady Paradise, when is it proper for a young gentleman to put his feet round a lady’s waist when glissading? Mollie. Dear Mollie: Before doing this, my dear, you must be sure that you have been properly introduced by a Presbyterian minister, or, failing him, by the camp cook.
Please tell me, dear Lady Paradise, the proper etiquette in connection with the use of the rubber cup, when climbing. –Bill Always give it first, Bill, to the lady who you know has the most chocolate concealed about her person.
Further Readingon the Experience of Early Travellers in the Canadian Rockies
MacLaren, I.S., Ed. Culturing Wilderness in Jasper National Park: Studies in Two Centuries of Human History in the Upper Athabasca River Watershed. Edmonton, AB: University of Alberta Press, 2007.
Reichwein, Pearlann. Climber’s Paradise: Making Canada’s Mountain Parks, 1906-1974. Edmonton, AB: University of Alberta Press, 2014.
Skidmore, Colleen, Ed. This Wild Spirit: Women in the Rocky Mountains of Canada. Edmonton, AB: University of Alberta Press, 2006.
Skidmore, Colleen. Women Wilderness Photography: Searching for Mary Schäffer. Edmonton, AB: University of Alberta Press, 2017.
Seton-Thompson, Grace Gallatin. A Woman Tenderfoot. New York: Doubleday, Page, and Co., 1900.
History Research Shenanigans 